Tasting with your eye
Tasting with your eye happens with food and we have all come to expect a certain kind of aesthetic in restaurants. If you eat out a lot you won’t blink if your chips/fried are served in a plant pot or your steak comes to you on a piece of slate. The days of Chicken in a basket – unless the basket is woven by hand – are over.
In actual fact I know a restaurateur who takes great pains to ensure the aesthetic of the place is just so – she sits for hours on end with “mood boards”, swapping different swatches of coloured cloth in order to have the chairs match the walls and the walls match the tables. She got in an electrician to move the lights around to make the perfect ambience and she’ll spend days flicking through the magazines that are to be placed in the rack to convey the image she wants her space to reflect. It is this little extra attention to detail that has made her restaurant very successful.
She also worries about what cups and glassware to use. The same cannot be said about all restaurant owners indeed and all bar owners too. It can often be a completely overlooked aspect of the experience eating or drinking out experience. The worst I’ve had is tea served in a cup that smelt of wet cloth, pilsners served in hot glasses straight out of the dishwasher or wine served in a plastic beaker. It might sound like I’m a fussy bastard. However, I think being lazy when it comes to how you serve your drinks makes a massive difference. I have personal experience in this avenue and have learned the hard way just how much of a difference it can make.
The first few times I made vermouth I neglected my thoughts on the aesthetic, I was instead thinking about how it might have been made originally. I made the caramel from very dark, unrefined sugar loaves that I’d picked up from a market. This was mistake number one, the next mistake was how it was served, I poured it from a half filled two litre green plastic bottle. Part of the old label was half hanging off. I then poured it into mismatching plastic camping mugs. I thought it tasted very good, but I will admit that it looked like pond water. Unsurprisingly, no one particularly cared for it.
I glanced across the bar and noticed how wonderfully clear looking crimson red drinks were being served up from very good looking glass bottles into clear mock crystal glasses and they were being lapped up. I pondered this for a few moments, were people really tasting with their eye.
My next batch of vermouth was made using white sugar to make the caramel, allowing the natural colours to come through. My vermouth became crystal clear and with a hint of red; some would say perhaps even slightly pink. I served this from a good looking clear glass bottle and went to the effort of sourcing an old style label for it. Suddenly, everyone wanted some. It was essentially the same drink as you can hear on this BBC Radio four food programme.
I don’t do my booze walks nearly so often these days, but when I do I always think about the aesthetic. I always use glass bottles with and I write the ingredients out on neatly drawn luggage tags. I also ensure the glassware matches, if available I even add a crafted garnish. Murky drinks don’t get a look in, nor does cheap looking plastic.
Tasting with your eye – The science bit

It has been long documented that visual cues are known to be very powerful cues in how we taste. Indeed, one of the most famous booze world experiments was when wine tasters were given white wine that was flavoured with red food colouring. It was recreated by TV host Stephan Gates and he gave members of a London wine club Pinot Gris coloured to look like a pale, red wine. They all thought they were drinking red wine and when he revealed to them what they were actually drinking it was met with shock and surprise.
If more evidence was needed for tasting with your eye, a rather more scholarly test was conducted in a joint study between Oxford University and the Polytechnic University of Valencia. They gave 57 volunteers identical hot chocolate in four different cups coloured orange, white, red, and cream. After drinking they were asked to rate it on a sliding scale for sweetness, aroma, enjoyment and sweetness. Orange and cream cups won out on flavour and white cups scored the lowest.
It is perhaps not unsurprising that the look of a drink can drastically alter our taste when we consider that the retina is actually an outgrowth of the brain and that around 30% of our neurons are devoted to visual processing. Indeed, it is now believed that our eyes are so powerful that we can detect a single photon of light in an otherwise darkened room.
Ok, but what can I do about it?
What does this mean for practical use for bartenders, restaurant owners, and those serving drinks all day in a cafe? It’s quite simple really, it really means that you shouldn’t underestimate how much your cups and glasses say about your establishment. Even if your customers are not as fussy as I am they will be making assumptions about your establishment on an unconscious level with each drink served. Perhaps it is time to ditch the polystyrene cups and you need to start serving your chicken in a basket in a hand-woven willow whip basket rather than a plastic one. Of course, there is always the danger of going too far the other way and coming across like some kind of ponce – sandwiches in a glass, dessert in an ash tray and a cocktail in a light bulb are just plain wrong.
References





