Tips for the nervous forager
Are you a nervous forager? Have you heard too many horror stories about foraging? You’d like to give it a go but you think there is a real possibility that if you do, you’ll poison yourself and perhaps your family too.
If I may let you into a little secret. Being nervous about something that CAN potentially kill you is a good thing. Despite foraging for a vast proportion of my life, on occasion, I still have these worries I’ll explain why I think by being a bit of a nervous forager you are actually the best kind of forager.
Forgetfulness and anxiety
You know those moments when you just can’t quite bring a word to mind? Mostly it seems to happen at a party when you are about to introduce someone. It can be embarrassing, but at least it’s not deadly. However it might cost you a friendship. According to a Scottish study, it’s best to blunder right through and pretend that you do remember someone name. The person being forgotten will feel less close to you and it could also lower their self-esteem.
Luckily, plants don’t have the same feelings – (we think). But this momentary amnesia can also happen when foraging and then it can be a little dangerous. Of course it’s fine if you forget the name of a plant, as long as you recognise it, but what if the mental block means you forget about the edibility of a plant?
Well on the occasions that this happens to me, I simply don’t pick the plant. Sometimes it will come back to me just as I walk away and other times I have to go back to my books and double check with botanical drawings. Then and only then do I pick it.
I know this is just nervousness, anxiety bought on by a fragment of an underdone potato, stress, lack of sleep or all the other things that can cause momentary Anomic Aphasia. Even so, I choose to avoid picking that plant at that moment.
It’s a little habit, a tic that has kept me alive. It’s better than the opposite, bravado and arrogance. If I may, I’ll tell you a little story about where they can get you.
Stay a little nervous
Once there was a chef who was happily foraging on the coastline of a Scottish Island. He’d just had a few days of full immersion foraging, courtesy of myself and Mark Williams. He knew it all and popped a bit of Hemlock Waterdropwort into his mouth. Luckily, a foraging barman someone saw him and urged him to spit it out. The reason he ate it? Arrogance!

I might sound harsh, I mean I really liked this chef and in other ways, he was a great chap but at that moment he was an arrogant fool.
And that’s all it takes one moment of arrogance, of overconfidence a moment when you don’t listen to your doubts.
Every forager I’ve met has one main warning – Don’t pick unless you are 100% sure of what you are picking. What I am describing here in this post is that statement in action.
Being a little bit of a nervous forager is a habit that I adopted many years ago and it’s one that has served me well.
It has kept me alive. It has meant that I’m overly cautious with all the plants in the carrot family, with many mushrooms and with plants in different countries. Below is an illustrative example of how that plays out.
Norfolk Island Pine – A pine to be nervous about

Just recently I was in Maderia, I found a tree that was new to me – The Norfolk Island pine. It smelt great, and as a result, was a joy to be around. I thought it might make a nice addition to the botanicals in a gin I was making.
But then that nervous feeling kicked in, after all I was around many new plants and in a new country. It didn’t pay to just go sticking anything in my mouth.
Then one of our group, a very knowledgeable plantswoman called Christine Walkden (who gives a great plant talk). Said something that set that nervous feeling a flame. “and it’s not even a pine”.
Two neurons must have found a path back together as some dusty old memory triggered. I’d written about this plant – in Fermenting Everything. I’d even described it as “not a true pine”, but more to the point my description said, “poisonous”!
Once again that niggle, that nervousness helped me live on another day.
How to get over being a nervous forager
The main thing to think about if you are really worried is that foraging is a skill, a craft. Skill and crafts take time to learn, you can add one or two plants a month or even a year to your knowledge and slowly build up your confidence. Learning about simple botany helps, as does learning about as many of the poisonous plants in your country as you can.
I’d also highly recomend looking up an experienced forager and going out on an organised walk. Then buy a bunch of foraging books and binge watch a bunch of videos. Just learn however you learn best and remember to stay a little bit nervous and remember – Don’t pick unless you are 100% sure of what you are picking.





