Tapping walnut (and other) trees
Recently, I found myself chatting about birch sap with a fellow forager Rob Gould (Cotswold Forager) I’ve written extensively about tapping birch, for the Guardian, on this site and in my book Booze For Free. I’ve always advocated drilling into the tree to get your sap, then plugging it up to stop the flow. Rob pointed out that this might not be the healthiest for the tree.
The case against Tapping trees
Using anecdotal evidence gathered from foresters Rob told me that, especially down here in the South of England, between 20-50% of the trees that are tapped might die off within the next five years. This is because the further south of the Arctic Circle you go the less insulation the tree needs. The insulation takes the form of the inner protective layer of bark, the cambium layer and the papery bark around the tree. Put quite simply, southern trees might just not be hardy enough for tapping.
If this turns out to be true, climate change might see the end of tapping or the end of the birch.
Pruning rather than tapping
Luckily, there is another way of tapping the birch, and other trees, that won’t damage it to the same extent. That is the pruning or clipping method. This is rather self-explanatory, typically, you need to find a branch that is as thick as grown man’s thumb then you prune or clip the end of it. You then affix your containers on the ends of each branch. As Rob states, this is no more harmful to the tree than when high winds lop off the edge of a branch.
In fact, the whole reason I ended up writing this post is because the end of one of the branches on my smaller walnut tree was somehow lopped off naturally. I noted it was covered in white sugar and thought, bingo bango it’s sap time.
Walnut tapping – walnut clipping/pruning
Once I saw the clipped branch I decided to try this method this year on the larger squirrel planted walnut Juglans regina in my garden. It’s far too close to mine and my neighbour’s houses and so I prune it every year anyway to keep relations sweet.
To give some context on size and age I didn’t notice the tree in 2011 when we first moved in but did the next year. So I estimate it to be roughly 12 years old. It currently stands about 4 meters, I had to lop the top off last year for fear of it taking over (my garden is really too small for such a tree). I think it would be about 5 meters tall had I not. The trunk is 15-20cm thick.
I tapped late, across the first week of April. March had been cold and wet throughout, so I suspect that aided the late flow.
I clipped three branches in total and gathered 1 litre/2 pints of sap. It tasted fresh and delicious, reminding me of drinking from a cool mountain stream in the Alps. I haven’t yet made the syrup and will update this post when I do.





